Coca-Cola has introduced it’s releasing a brand new Coke product this fall that’s sweetened with cane sugar reasonably than high-fructose corn syrup. The announcement adopted a July Reality Social submit wherein President Donald Trump claimed he satisfied Coke to vary its product.
To be truthful, we don’t know whether or not Trump thinks cane sugar simply tastes higher, or whether or not he wished to enhance Coke’s dietary profile, or if the choice was pushed by political causes. However regardless, this transfer has been hailed as a victory by Health and Human Providers Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and his Make America Wholesome Once more Fee.
However is cane sugar actually any higher than high-fructose corn syrup (HCFS), from a dietary perspective? The proof strongly factors to no.
Right here’s why: Whereas HFCS positively doesn’t do any favors for human well being, neither does cane sugar. An excessive amount of added sugar — no matter which sort or what meals it’s in — could cause spikes in blood sugar ranges and has been linked with many various power well being circumstances, from sort 2 diabetes to coronary heart illness and weight problems. Soda, which is loaded with added sugars, is an unhealthy meals selection whether or not it’s sweetened with high-fructose corn syrup or cane sugar.
Maria Korneeva through Getty Pictures
“Replacing cane sugar with high-fructose corn syrup does not have any meaningful effect on health — including blood pressure, glucose metabolism or any measure of cardiometabolic health,” mentioned Maddie Pasquariello, a New York Metropolis-based registered dietitian (RD).
Right here’s what you’ll want to find out about cane sugar and HFCS — and why one isn’t actually any more healthy than the opposite, with experience shared by registered dietitians.
What’s the distinction between high-fructose corn syrup and cane sugar?
From a chemistry standpoint, high-fructose corn syrup and cane sugar are each sugars, they usually’re fairly related, together with containing the identical variety of energy — about 4 per gram.
Let’s begin with cane sugar. Because the title implies, cane sugar is constructed from the sugarcane plant, and is made up of sucrose, the most typical sort of sugar. Sucrose is shaped by way of the becoming a member of of two easy sugars — glucose and fructose (each monosaccharides) — which makes it a disaccharide.
“Replacing cane sugar with high-fructose corn syrup does not have any meaningful effect on health.”
– Maddie Pasquariello, RD
Excessive-fructose corn syrup is a sweetener constructed from corn syrup. Nutritionally, HFCS is similar to desk sugar (sucrose), which can also be manufactured from glucose and fructose in roughly a 50/50 break up. Nevertheless, not like sucrose, which is a disaccharide (the place the 2 sugars are bonded collectively), HFCS comprises glucose and fructose as particular person monosaccharides. In high-fructose corn syrup, “the two are not bonded together and the ratio might be slightly different than 50/50 in the overall product,” Pasquariello mentioned. Due to its sweetness, stability and low price, HFCS is often used within the meals trade, particularly in sodas, packaged snacks, condiments and desserts.
Are there well being advantages to consuming drinks made with cane sugar reasonably than high-fructose corn syrup?
Regardless of any claims you might have heard from cane sugar advocates — equivalent to these calling high-fructose corn syrup poison, or suggesting it’s uniquely dangerous to the liver and extra strongly linked to power sicknesses like weight problems and kind 2 diabetes — there aren’t any advantages to consuming cane sugar reasonably than HFCS. Each sweeteners have related results on the physique when consumed in related quantities. “Your body cannot tell the difference once they are broken down and enter the bloodstream,” Pasquariello mentioned. “Calorically, metabolically — it doesn’t matter.”
Based on the FDA, high-fructose corn syrup isn’t any much less secure by way of the way it’s metabolized by the physique than cane sugar and different widespread sweeteners like honey. Some critics have blamed HFCS for rising weight problems charges, pointing to a development of rising weight problems charges similtaneously growing consumption of HFCS. However vitamin consultants say that declare is unfounded. Within the e book “Unsavory Truth: How Food Companies Skew the Science of What We Eat,” nutritionist and public well being knowledgeable Marion Nestle identified that whereas the growing use of high-fructose corn syrup within the meals provide occurred alongside growing weight problems charges, that is an affiliation, however not essentially a trigger. “In reality, both sucrose and HFCS are sugars,” she wrote. “Both are best consumed in small amounts.”
Added sugars include energy, however apart from that they’re devoid of nutritional vitamins and minerals that help wholesome bodily functioning. Consuming a beverage sweetened with 25 grams of added sugar from cane sugar has the identical affect on the physique as a beverage sweetened with 25 grams of added sugar from HFCS.
Analysis reveals that when evaluating cane sugar (sucrose) and high-fructose corn syrup, there aren’t vital variations by way of the physique’s metabolic or endocrine responses and opposed well being outcomes like weight problems. Due to this, eradicating HFCS from meals manufacturing wouldn’t have a significant affect on the metabolism, well being or weight problems charges of Individuals, defined RD Jaime Gnau, medical assistant professor within the College of Health Sciences at Missouri State College.
“What makes a difference for health is your overall added sugar consumption on a long-term basis — not the source of the sugar,” Pasquariello mentioned.
Merely put: swapping out high-fructose corn syrup for cane sugar doubtless isn’t going to learn your well being. However reducing again on sugar-sweetened drinks and limiting added sugars will — and this consists of any type of sugar, from cane sugar or HFCS to agave, honey, maple syrup or coconut sugar.
“Switching to a beverage with less added sugar would be of much more benefit than changing the type of sugar in the drink,” mentioned Kristine Dilley, a registered dietitian nutritionist (RDN) at The Ohio State College Wexner Medical Middle.
Why does general sugar consumption matter?
Based on the Dietary Tips for Individuals, added sugars needs to be restricted to lower than 10% of somebody’s each day caloric consumption, which quantities to about 50 grams of sugar per day for somebody who’s consuming a 2,000 calorie eating regimen. And that’s the higher restrict — they really advocate aiming for even much less. In the meantime, the American Coronary heart Affiliation suggests even stricter limits for added sugars — 24 grams per day for girls and 36 grams per day for males.
And added sugars add up rapidly. Only a 12-ounce can of Coca Cola comprises 39 grams of added sugars, and barely is that the one sugar somebody is consuming in a day. Added sugar is present in excessive quantities in all kinds of processed meals, from cereal to yogurt to condiments.
“Overconsumption of added sugar has negative outcomes for body weight, blood pressure, insulin sensitivity, and other cardiometabolic risk factors,” Pasquariello mentioned. “The use of cane sugar in a sugar-sweetened beverage instead of HFCS doesn’t make it any less likely to be over-consumed.”
After all sugar isn’t at all times a nasty factor. “Sugar provides fast energy and is a great tool for endurance athletes to perform their best,” Gnau mentioned. “The more active you are, the more energy you need.” Nonetheless, most Individuals are consuming an excessive amount of sugar and not shifting sufficient. Based on the CDC, simply 1 in 4 Individuals meet bodily exercise tips. And should you’re not shifting sufficient and offering your physique with a means to make use of vitality from excessive added sugar consumption, well being dangers rise, Gnau added.
