This text is a part of HuffPost’s biweekly politics e-newsletter. Click on right here to subscribe.
When the digicam panned to the viewers of Vice President Kamala Harris’ concession speech Wednesday, a lot of her supporters had been actually weeping. Had cameras been in a position to peer into houses across the nation, they in all probability would have discovered loads of tears there, too.
“Sometimes the fight takes a while,” the defeated 2024 Democratic presidential nominee stated as she wrapped up her remarks, maybe with these very individuals in thoughts. “That doesn’t mean we won’t win. The important thing is, don’t ever give up. Don’t ever give up. Don’t ever stop trying to make the world a better place.”
The plea had a sure poignance, coming because it did from the second girl in a decade to run for the presidency and lose to Donald Trump. It was additionally delivered in a really completely different context than Hillary Clinton’s 2016 concession to the Republican. Trump has turn into extra excessive within the intervening years, extra unbalanced. His 2024 marketing campaign featured “naked racism and misogyny,” as my colleague Nathalie Baptiste wrote this week, whereas promising mass deportations of migrants and a radical overhaul of the federal authorities. Members of his earlier administration have even referred to as him a fascist.
Harris wasn’t the one Democratic chief urging resilience within the face of Trump’s victory. “We all get knocked down, but the measure of our character, as my dad would say, is how quickly we get back up,” President Joe Biden acknowledged in a Thursday speech on the White Home. “Remember, a defeat does not mean we are defeated.”
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) tinged her plea, delivered over social media, with a warning. “We are about to enter a political period that will have consequences for the rest of our lives. We cannot give up,” she stated.
In fact, such exhortations are commonplace fare in dropping political causes: We misplaced at present; we’ll win tomorrow. Sustain the great combat. However these phrases could also be unusually obligatory now, due to the important function that political opposition performed after Trump’s final electoral win ― and the open query of whether or not such opposition will materialize once more.
What 2017 Was Like
It’s been nearly a decade, so it’s simple to overlook the sheer sense of shock that adopted Trump’s 2016 election. Many individuals simply couldn’t fathom that Trump might really win the White Home. After which he did.
The quick impact on the political left was paralysis. However that shortly gave solution to anger and dedication. An natural backlash took form ― in small social circles, on-line and off, till ultimately it coalesced right into a loosely organized nationwide motion led by teams just like the newly shaped Indivisible Venture.
As Trump took workplace in 2017, there have been airport demonstrations towards his journey and immigration restrictions, in addition to a march for ladies’s rights in Washington. When Trump tried to repeal the Inexpensive Care Act, there was an outpouring of opposition at congressional city halls across the nation and ultimately on Capitol Hill itself.
This pushback nearly definitely made a distinction. The Obamacare protests helped save the legislation, which remains to be round at present. Immigration protests modified the politics of the difficulty in a method that ― as broadcaster Chris Hayes famous not too long ago on MSNBC ― probably compelled Trump to again down on household separations later in his time period.
Justin Sullivan by way of Getty Photos
The Ladies’s March on Washington didn’t cease Trump from putting in the Supreme Courtroom majority that might overturn Roe v. Wade, the 1973 ruling that had legalized abortion nationwide. However it set in place the activist groundwork to maintain abortion rights and gender points within the public eye, and fueled the political wave that elected Democrats within the subsequent two midterms after which Biden in 2020.
What 2025 May Be Like
Now Trump is on his method again to the White Home. This time there’s no shock on the left, or no less than not the identical type of shock. Everybody knew he might win, not simply because the polls had been so shut however just because he had executed it earlier than. Lots of his opponents had ready for the likelihood months in the past, when Biden was nonetheless the Democratic nominee and nicely behind within the polls.
However there are additionally indicators of despair and fatigue, as The New York Instances reported Wednesday. Democrats and their allies have been at this for almost 10 years, preventing Trump and Trumpism, solely to be again on the beginning line as soon as once more.
“The Second American Republic (1868-2024) is over,” Democratic Get together advocate and adviser Dmitri Mehlhorn wrote in a letter that ended up on social media, stating what quite a lot of others had been saying privately. “I threw everything I had into defending it. That fight is done. … I’m heading back to the private sector.”
In some methods, such resignation is a part of a pure course of. Some activists and advocates make a profession out of selling their causes. However many will do it for under a time, steadily of their 20s and 30s when they’re stuffed with postcollege idealism and comparatively unencumbered. Then they transfer on to different pursuits, a brand new era of energetic idealists take their place, and the cycle repeats.
The cycle might hold going — it’s solely been a couple of days — particularly if Trump follows via on guarantees like his mass deportations vow after he takes workplace subsequent 12 months. The sounds and sights of officers pulling pals and neighbors out of workplaces and houses, and ripping aside households, have the potential to be extra polarizing than the pictures of separated children that took maintain of the American consciousness throughout Trump’s first time period.
It’s even potential that this new era could have sure benefits. Youthful activists could higher perceive how you can combat Trumpism on the terrain the place it’s thriving, whether or not that’s life-style podcasts or male-oriented social media platforms. Their willingness to simply accept Trump and Trumpism as simply one other a part of American politics could assist them attain the numerous voters who fairly clearly really feel the identical method.
And exhausted or not, it’s clear that numerous the previous activists — and fairly a couple of new ones — are already gearing up for the combat.
Democracy In The Stability
Already contributed? Log in to cover these messages.
On Thursday evening, a bunch of progressive organizations together with MoveOn.org and the Working Households Get together held a digital assembly led by Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-Wash.). Indivisible was additionally a part of the hassle. Leah Greenberg, its co-founder and co-executive director, instructed me metrics confirmed that greater than 137,000 individuals had been on the decision and that greater than 8,000 signed up as “hosts” for native organizing efforts sooner or later.
“What we’re hearing from people is both sorrow and determination,” Greenberg stated. “And what we are seeing from the metrics is that people who were previously engaged and who are not engaged, they are reengaging. Other people are newly engaging or figuring to ramp up.”
Hope can, after all, be a strategic transfer. In a video launched on-line after Trump’s win this week, Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) — who grew to become the inspiration for a rallying cry throughout Trump’s first time period — didn’t simply name for resistance towards Trump, however resistance towards despair.
“The far right wants us to feel powerless. Extremists are counting on apathy, cynicism, heartbreak or all of the above as their rocket fuel,” she stated. “I absolutely refuse to give them that satisfaction.”
People should wait and see whether or not the resistance will persist, nonetheless.
