WASHINGTON ― It was all memes and shit-posting when billionaire Elon Musk first instructed in August he may lead a “Department of Government Efficiency” if Donald Trump gained the White Home once more.
A reporter had requested Trump after a marketing campaign occasion in York, Pennsylvania, if he would take into account naming Musk to a Cupboard place, one thing he had not beforehand instructed, and Trump eagerly stated he would.
“I am willing to serve,” Musk wrote in response, alongside an synthetic picture of himself at a lectern bearing the identify of his imaginary company.
The entire thing was actually a joke. The division identify is a reference to a throwback web meme primarily based on an image of a Shiba Inu canine, “Doge,” which served as inspiration for Musk’s favourite cryptocurrency token. That was additionally created as a joke.
This story is a part of HuffPost’s dedication to fearlessly masking the Trump administration. You may assist our work and defend the free press by contributing to our newsroom.
For some time, it appeared like DOGE itself may flip right into a joke, merely an up to date model of previous deficit-reduction panels. However after the election, Trump introduced DOGE could be an actual entity, one thing to “provide advice and guidance from outside of Government.” By Inauguration Day, Trump had issued an government order creating DOGE as an workplace inside the White Home, with Musk as a short lived worker serving for 130 days. Issues obtained severe quick.
DOGE burned maybe too brightly, and 100 days later, we appear to be within the twilight of the Musk period in Trump’s authorities. The chainsaw-wielding billionaire promised Tesla shareholders final week that he would quickly spend much less time on his authorities work. Final week, Trump noticeably described Musk up to now tense: “He was a tremendous help.”
DOGE has modified the federal government, however not in the way in which Musk or Trump promised. Musk vowed final yr to seek out $2 trillion in financial savings from the practically $7 trillion federal price range. He later lowered his goal to $1 trillion, which was nonetheless an absurd purpose as a result of Congress controls federal spending, and Trump has promised to not contact common retirement packages that symbolize the largest segments of federal spending.
After months of infiltrating federal companies, unlawfully accessing delicate authorities knowledge and imposing mass chaos and layoffs, a seated and subdued Musk stated at a Cupboard assembly this month that his staff would ship a mere $150 billion — a determine he nonetheless hasn’t been capable of present an accounting for.
In the meantime, the federal authorities has already spent more cash this yr than it did final yr, in line with estimates from the Congressional Price range Workplace. Price range specialists assume it’s absolutely attainable DOGE, with its cuts to the revenue-gathering IRS and payouts to departing staff, might find yourself costing the federal authorities cash.
“What a waste of everyone’s time and money.”
– A just lately former IRS worker
The evident irony amid all of that is that the so-called Division of Authorities Effectivity has resulted in widespread inefficiencies throughout authorities companies. Keep in mind Musk’s mandate from a few months in the past that a whole bunch of hundreds of federal staff ship in 5 bullet factors each week to their managers, outlining what they did through the week? A minimum of some staff are nonetheless doing this, and it’s completely pointless.
“As far as we can tell, no one is reading them,” stated one Protection Division worker who requested anonymity to guard their job. “I send them with read receipts requested and have never got notification of them being read. It is annoying and time-consuming and just insulting.”
A now-former IRS worker who DOGE put by the wringer earlier than she lastly give up this month ― she and her total staff of 30 individuals had been fired, then rehired, then placed on administrative go away, then pressured to resign, then warned of extra firings coming ― stated that if something is obvious, it’s that DOGE has plowed by the federal government like “a wrecking ball” with none understanding of what it’s doing or how something works.
This former IRS worker, who requested anonymity as she begins a brand new job, was working within the property and reward tax division, which fits after extraordinarily rich tax evaders. Most of her division is being gutted, so lots of the instances it has been engaged on must be closed.
“My division collects MILLIONS in tax revenue for the American people,” she stated in an e-mail. “What a waste of everyone’s time and money. Several people will now not pay what they owe to the American people, and they will continue to not pay because there is no one there to ensure their compliance. And, this doesn’t make anything more efficient.”
DOGE has misplaced its preliminary shine, too. Musk’s approval score sank to 35% in a Washington Put up / ABCNews / Ipsos ballot launched Monday.
Bloomberg through Getty Photos
One purpose individuals could also be over Musk is due to his resolution to assault Social Safety, one of many authorities’s hottest packages, as a bastion of fraud and waste.
Musk claimed in February that tens of millions of individuals over the age of 110 years outdated had been falsely listed as nonetheless alive within the Social Safety Administration’s system, suggesting the company was sending out fraudulent checks. Trump repeated the declare in a speech to Congress, despite the fact that it wasn’t true. In March, Musk went on to name Social Safety a “Ponzi scheme,” a rip-off swindling Individuals out of their payroll contributions for no future profit.
Musk used these claims to justify main adjustments on the company, together with cuts to a cellphone service that will have compelled tens of millions of seniors to journey to company discipline places of work to file for retirement advantages. Musk claimed, with out proof, that the change was mandatory due to fraudsters bombarding the federal government with phone requests to modify individuals’s checking account data with a view to siphon their advantages.
“This is happening all day, every day, and then somebody doesn’t receive their Social Security. It’s because of all the fraud loopholes in the Social Security system,” Musk claimed in March, massively overstating the extent of fraudulent requests to alter financial institution accounts.
In spite of everything of Musk’s hype about this menace, the Social Safety Administration wound up suspending after which calling off the cuts to the cellphone service for individuals submitting profit claims, saying it had discovered a brand new technique to stop phone fraud in spite of everything.
Democrats might not have a nationwide chief or a coherent plan to counter Trump, however Musk’s assaults on Social Safety have made him an virtually excellent villain, permitting Democrats to undercut Trump’s try to place himself as a champion of this system.
As DOGE winds down its efforts, individuals outdoors of Washington, D.C., are beginning to really feel the adverse results of what Musk has completed. One Social Safety discipline workplace employee informed HuffPost this week they’re seeing longer traces and angrier prospects as a result of persons are seeing information tales about Musk’s antics and worrying their advantages are in hassle. On the identical time, Musk’s layoffs have made it even tougher to maintain up with the workload.
“They’re doing everything they can to hinder people from getting the benefits they paid for,” the sector workplace employee stated. “It’s making it look like the government is broken and it’s not. It’s broken because people who don’t understand it are trying to run it.”
Consideration federal staff: When you have ideas to share on how DOGE has created effectivity and financial savings at your company ― or on the way it has completed the alternative ― we’d love to listen to from you. Drop us a line: Jen.Bendery@huffpost.com
