State Auditor Diana DiZoglio needs to cost $2,000 to satisfy a public data request for paperwork that element the behind-the-scenes work of an audit into the state-run shelter system, an inquiry her workplace’s high lawyer characterised as a “fishing expedition.”
A shelter audit launched final month accused Gov. Maura Healey’s administration of inking “improper and unlawful” no-bid contracts for meals and transportation providers for the shelter system. However Healey’s high deputies pushed again in opposition to the report, arguing it “missed the urgent need for reform.”
In a Might 21 request, the Herald sought emails from Jan. 1, 2024, to Might 21, 2025, between the official in DiZoglio’s workplace who helped oversee the audit, communications aides within the Workplace of the State Auditor and Govt Workplace of Housing and Livable Communities, and head attorneys in each places of work.
The request additionally requested for draft copies of the audit that had been supplied to the Govt Workplace of Housing and Livable Communities, the state company that oversees the shelter system, by the Workplace of the State Auditor, and any official communications between the 2 entities that pertained to the audit.
However 15 days after the data request was submitted, DiZoglio — who was elected to workplace on marketing campaign pledges to “fight for transparency, accountability, and equity” — put a $2,000 price ticket on the paperwork.
“If Mr. Van Buskirk would like staff to stop auditing and instead spend the next two weeks compiling and reviewing over 22,800 records for his fishing expedition, we have provided him with the fee estimate in accordance with the public records law,” DiZoglio’s normal counsel, Michael Leung-Tat, stated in a press release to the Herald.
The Herald filed the request to see how the ultimate draft of the audit was developed and shine a lightweight on how DiZoglio’s workplace interacts with state businesses in the course of the course of an investigation.
In a June 5 electronic mail to the Herald, Leung-Tat stated the data request turned up roughly 22,800 emails, a batch that may allegedly take 4 hours to evaluation and acquire.
A workers member for the Workplace of the State Auditor would then must spend 76 hours to “search and produce electronic files for responsive records,” in keeping with Leung-Tat, who estimated that 5 emails might be reviewed per minute.
A workers lawyer would then be tasked with redacting or withholding data underneath a number of exemptions — privateness, deliberative course of, attorney-work product, and attorney-client privilege, Leung-Tat stated.
Leung-Tat stated the bottom hourly charge to look and produce the data is $25 per hour, bringing the fee for 84 hours of labor to $2,100. The state’s public data legislation requires the primary 4 hours of labor to be free, which brings the overall charge estimate to supply the data to $2,000.
“Please note that the actual cost to fulfill your public records request may vary from this good-faith estimate once the OSA begins preparing the records pursuant to your request. OSA requires payment of this estimated fee prior to fulfilling your public records request,” Leung-Tat stated.
The Herald filed an enchantment with Secretary of State William Galvin’s workplace difficult the price of fulfilling the general public data request.
The Govt Workplace of Housing and Livable Communities didn’t try and cost the Herald for a similar data, however as an alternative declined to launch paperwork underneath the deliberative course of exemption. The exemption permits the company to withhold “memoranda or letters relating to policy positions being developed by the agency.”
The company acknowledged that “records responsive to your request” exist, however stated it couldn’t launch paperwork as a result of the emergency shelter audit is “not yet complete.” DiZoglio’s workplace “intends to follow up” on her findings in six months, the company stated.
“As such, EOHLC is withholding all responsive records as the findings and implementation are still under consideration and policy deliberation,” stated Jessica Ellis, deputy normal counsel for the Govt Workplace of Housing and Livable Communities.
The Herald plans to enchantment the data request denial.
DiZoglio’s workplace is searching for to cost the Herald for public data roughly two months after it accused the newspaper of defaming her in an article that stated the Methuen Democrat admitted to conflicts of curiosity with the Legislature in a collection of types she signed over the previous a number of years.
Along with auditing the shelter system, DiZoglio is pursuing an investigation into the interior workings of the Massachusetts Home and Senate after the profitable passage of a poll query she championed final yr.
DiZoglio is a former lawmaker who has publicly criticized high Democrats on social media for not complying along with her audit of the Legislature. Lawmakers contend that the legislative audit violates the separation of powers ideas discovered within the state structure.
In an April 11 letter to the Herald’s writer, Leung-Tat stated DiZoglio has “never ‘admitted’ to having ‘conflicts of interest with the Legislature’ — because none exist.”
“This reckless disregard towards the truth is a disservice to the Herald’s readers,” Leung-Tat stated.
However Jeffrey Robbins, a lawyer for the Herald, shot again at Leung-Tat’s April letter.
“In candor, your letter is difficult to take seriously given Auditor DiZoglio’s express and repeated admissions in her annual independence certification forms and the unquestionably accurate statements contained in the Herald’s article reporting on Auditor DiZoglio’s admissions contained in those public forms,” Robbins stated in an April 16 letter to Leung-Tat.
Initially Printed:
