An ex-state trooper who gave passing scores to Business Driver’s License candidates even when they failed the check ought to serve 15 months in jail, in response to the feds who’re citing “recent police corruption scandals” within the Bay State.
Halifax man Calvin Butner, 64, a former Massachusetts State Police trooper whose pension is greater than $72,000 a yr, pleaded responsible in reference to the CDL testing scheme.
He conspired with ex-Sgt. Gary Cederquist and different former troopers to offer false passing scores to CDL candidates related to Butner and different members of the CDL Unit.
“For years, Trooper Calvin Butner betrayed his State Police badge to dole out favors to friends and family members, all the while jeopardizing the safety of anyone on the roads and highways of Massachusetts and beyond,” the feds wrote of their sentencing memo.
“The core dishonesty demonstrated by Trooper Butner, a sworn member of the Massachusetts State Police who held himself out as an upstanding law enforcement officer, is outrageous and inexcusable,” the feds added.
The Massachusetts U.S. Legal professional’s workplace is looking for a sentence of 15 months in federal jail, one yr of supervised launch, and the necessary particular evaluation of $900.
Butner is about to be sentenced in Boston federal courtroom on Tuesday.
“Particularly given the specter of recent police corruption scandals in Massachusetts, the conduct exposed in this case underscores the need for this Court to impose a sentence that takes general deterrence into account and sends a message that this type of criminal conduct by members of law enforcement will not be tolerated,” the feds wrote.
“A sentence that includes a meaningful period of incarceration is necessary to deter others similarly situated to Trooper Butner – that is, members of MSP and other members of law enforcement – who might be tempted to engage in a similar course of conduct,” they added. “A sentence without a serious period of incarceration would not accomplish this goal.”
In 2022, Butner took dwelling practically $160,000 — together with $102,712 in base pay and $57,180 in different pay.
A CDL is required to drive a business automobile, similar to a tractor trailer, field truck, or faculty bus. A CDL applicant should show that they’ve detailed data of business automobiles, and so they additionally should carry out sure maneuvers and safely drive on public roadways, together with a freeway.
Butner and different members of the Mass State Police CDL Unit gave preferential remedy to at the least 17 CDL candidates by agreeing to provide passing scores on their CDL checks no matter whether or not they truly handed.
Among the candidates included Butner’s childhood buddy, a employee at a fence firm the place Butner was a buyer, and mutual acquaintances.
Butner and the co-defendants used the code phrase “golden” to determine these candidates. Butner texted the next feedback about candidates to a co-conspirator:
— “This guys a mess. . . . Lol. He owes u a prime rib 6inch.”
— “Golden mess. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣”
— “He’s a mess Class A truck 2psi loss with truck running truck cut our again while timing 🤣🤣🤣🤣”
— “Total mess this guy[.] i think some time[s] we should just do what we can but not golden. I’ll tell you about it later.”
The feds emphasised that Butner and the opposite troopers put motorists on the roads in danger.
“And not only did he do this, month after month, but he joked about it by text message with his co-conspirators, took measures to carefully conceal the conduct, and did not stop until he got caught,” the feds wrote.
“The conduct of participants in the golden conspiracy like Butner demonstrates a blatant disregard for the law and, more egregiously, a callous indifference for the safety of everyone on the roads and highways of Massachusetts,” they added.
Butner’s legal professional in his sentencing memo wrote that Butner acknowledges the seriousness of his conduct, and stated he has accepted full duty for his actions.
His lawyer is asking for a sentence of time served (in the future) adopted by one yr of supervised launch — with a situation that he serve a six-month time period of dwelling confinement.
“A sentence of imprisonment is simply unnecessary to specifically deter Mr. Butner from committing a future crime because of his age, the impact his prosecution has had on his wife and family, and the public humiliation he has suffered as the target of a high-profile federal prosecution,” Butner’s legal professional wrote.
“In light of these facts, the likelihood of Mr. Butner re-offending is near zero,” the lawyer added. “The defendant anticipates the government’s primary basis for recommending a jail sentence will be the need to promote respect for the law and deter others from committing similar crimes. Such arguments are understandable but a felony conviction, which will result in the collateral consequence of Mr. Butner forfeiting his pension, is itself a severe penalty under the circumstances of this case.”
Butner acquired a number of letters of help from members of the family and mates, who wrote to the federal decide forward of sentencing.
“My father is not someone who abuses power,” his daughter Tanya Figueroa wrote. “He’s somebody who has spent a lifetime following guidelines, taking orders, and bearing the burden of duty — usually quietly, at all times fully. The ache and regret he feels over this example are profound and deeply human.
“And for those of us who know him best, we grieve alongside him — not only for what has happened, but for how much it has shaken a man who has always stood tall,” she added. “This is not the story we imagined for my dad — but I ask with all the sincerity and love I hold as his daughter, that you see the man beyond the moment.”
Initially Revealed:
