Denis Villeneuve has a easy response for Quentin Tarantino lately saying that he refuses to look at Dune.
Simply final month, Quentin Tarantino shared a couple of scorching takes on latest motion pictures, together with his refusal to look at Denis Villeneuve’s Dune as a result of he’s already seen David Lynch’s model. “I saw [David Lynch’s] Dune a couple of times,” Tarantino mentioned. “I don’t have to see that story once more. I don’t have to see spice worms. I don’t have to see a film that claims the phrase ‘spice’ so dramatically.“
Villeneuve lately took half in a Q&A at Concordia College’s Mel Hoppenheim Faculty of Cinema in Montreal, the place he had a easy response to Tarantino’s refusal to look at Dune. “I don’t care,” Villeneuve mentioned, which prompted the viewers to erupt in laughter. Nevertheless, he did agree with Tarantino in a single space. “I agree with him that I don’t like this idea of recycling and bringing back old ideas,” he mentioned. “But where I disagree is that what I did was not a remake. It’s an adaptation of the book. I see this as an original.” Villeneuve then added, “However we’re very completely different human beings.“
I might say Tarantino is lacking out. Whereas Lynch’s film and Villeneuve’s motion pictures do share the identical supply in Frank Herbert’s novel, they’re very completely different animals.
“It’s one after another of this remake and that remake,” Tarantino mentioned. “People ask have you seen ‘Dune’? Have you seen ‘Ripley?’ Have you seen ‘Shōgun’?” And I’m like no, no, no, no. There’s six or seven Ripley books. Should you do one once more, why are you doing the identical one which they’ve performed twice already? I’ve seen that story twice earlier than, and I didn’t actually prefer it in both model, so I’m probably not involved in seeing it a 3rd time. Should you did one other story, that may be attention-grabbing sufficient to offer it a shot anyway.“
As for Dune, Villeneuve is ready to return to Arrakis for a 3rd installment of the franchise. Nevertheless, he’s mentioned that he doesn’t view Dune 3 because the completion of a trilogy. “First, it’s important that people understand that for me, it was really a diptych,” Villeneuve mentioned. “It was actually a pair of flicks that would be the adaptation of the primary guide. That’s performed and that’s completed. If I do a 3rd one, which is within the writing course of, it’s not like a trilogy. It’s unusual to say that, but when I’m going again there, it’s to do one thing that feels completely different and has its personal id.“
