Parchment paper, a generally used instrument in baking and cooking, has not too long ago been all of the speak on social media, with of us claiming that white and brown parchment paper aren’t equally protected to make use of within the kitchen.
On TikTok particularly, customers have been chronicling their grocery store journeys, extolling the praises of 1 sort of parchment paper over the opposite, with some additionally discovering third choices. Dig deep sufficient into the world of social media and also you’ll discover whole evaluations relating to particular manufacturers of every product. Clearly, folks have opinions.
We requested meals security specialists and nutritionists concerning the matter to seek out out whether or not we should always all the time go for one sort of parchment paper over the opposite.
What claims are folks making about brown and white parchment paper?
Chemically talking, the 2 merchandise differ in a single major side: brown parchment paper is unbleached and subsequently chlorine-free, whereas white parchment paper is bleached. Though no one actually appears to dispute that truth, the primary questions contain whether or not the bleached product is mechanically “bad” to your well being and whether or not it impacts the way in which meals is baked.
On Reddit particularly, there are whole threads devoted to the subject. “The color doesn’t affect the bake,” one consumer wrote. Another person on the platform revealed their distaste for any type of parchment paper “or single use kitchen product,” in a manner difficult everybody else’s stance on the brown vs. white parchment paper debate.
When and why ought to we use parchment paper within the first place?
“Parchment paper is great for baking cookies, roasting vegetables and any time you need a nonstick surface,” stated registered nutritionist and food plan guide Catherine Gervacio. “It prevents food from sticking, makes cleanup easier and can help with even cooking.”
After all, there are different choices like aluminum foil (which has additionally not too long ago come below hearth) that work properly with grilling, roasting, and different high-heat purposes. Nonetheless, foil isn’t nonstick and may require the usage of further sprays or oils that you could be fairly keep away from.
Not utilizing any type of wrapping within the oven “is also good,” stated Gervacio, however the apply could require a great deal of oil, which, in flip, will result in longer cleansing occasions and extra energy.
Grace Cary by way of Getty Photographs
The precise variations between brown and white parchment paper
The primary distinction between brown and white parchment paper entails the therapy of the product prior to make use of.
In line with meals scientist Bryan Quoc Le, a meals chemist and business guide primarily based in Washington state, white parchment paper is handled with chlorinating or oxidizing brokers. Brown parchment paper, however, doesn’t use as many chemical therapies in its manufacturing and is compostable.
As famous by Gervacio, chemically talking, the “white paper has undergone extra steps to remove its natural brown color.”
That being stated, Le defined that brown parchment paper is, paradoxically, extra energy-intensive to fabricate in contrast with white parchment paper.
“It contains a higher percentage of lignin [a natural polymer], which is more difficult to machine than treated white parchment paper,” he stated. So, white parchment paper is extra chemically handled, however brown parchment paper requires extra work to be stored in its pure kind.
The professionals and cons of brown vs. white
Consultants agree that, general, each forms of parchment paper yield comparable culinary outcomes by way of texture and taste. Nonetheless, there are specific execs and cons to remember when deciding on which product to make use of — most of them extremely depending on the chemical therapy concerned within the manufacturing of the gadgets.
“Brown paper is more eco-friendly because it’s unbleached, so there is reduced concern about potential chemical residues from bleaching,” stated Gervacio. Nonetheless, she additionally famous that the product will not be as extensively out there because the white possibility.
When discussing the advantages of white parchment paper, Le was fast to notice its increased hygiene worth.
“It allows [cooks] to see any contaminants easier than they would with brown parchment paper,” he stated, explaining that cooking on a white floor higher lets you see if there are any odd substances that made their manner into the meals.
Though much less eco-friendly, white parchment paper is mostly simpler to seek out within the common retailer, which could make it a greater possibility for some buyers.
We Want Your Help
Already contributed? Log in to cover these messages.
So does it even matter which one we use?
Though the variations between the 2 merchandise are extensively famous, Gervacio did level out that there haven’t but been research performed proving brown paper’s general superiority.
“Both brown and white parchment paper are safe to use, so there’s no need to stress,” she stated. “The brown version is seen as a slightly more eco-conscious choice because it’s unbleached, but it doesn’t offer extra nutritional benefits. It’s more about personal preference and environmental values than a health risk with either option.”
Le concurred. “Parchment paper is quite safe to use,” he stated, “as long as it does not reach its burning point of 425 degrees Fahrenheit in the oven.”
Nonetheless, if searching for an alternative choice completely, Gervacio suggests investing in silicone baking mats. “They are a reusable option that can reduce waste,” she stated. “Do know that parchment paper is compostable, though, while silicone mats are not biodegradable.”
