WASHINGTON — Donald Trump is already reneging on one of many guarantees he repeatedly made to a key voting bloc to win again the presidency, his vow to remove taxes on tens of millions of retirees’ Social Safety funds.
“No tax on Social Security benefits for our seniors,” he advised rallygoers in Prescott Valley, Arizona, on Oct. 13. “And you deserve it.”
“We will have no tax on tips, no tax on overtime, and no tax on Social Security benefits for our seniors,” he repeated at a rally in Greensboro, North Carolina, on Nov. 2.
After successful the November election and returning to the White Home, he has continued with the identical pledge. As lately as final week, throughout an interview with Fox Information host Sean Hannity aboard Air Pressure One, Trump repeated it but once more: “No tax on Social Security benefits for seniors, which is so great.”
HuffPost is dedicated to fearlessly masking the Trump administration. Click on right here to help our mission and turn into a member at this time.
In actuality, although, Trump and his congressional allies are providing Social Safety recipients a mere fraction of the monetary profit they’ve been promising since final yr. As a substitute of creating Social Safety advantages tax-free, Home Republicans have now included of their spending and tax lower plan a brand new $4,000 tax deduction for seniors — which interprets into an precise money good thing about lower than $500 for many retirees.
More comfortable retirees, these getting bigger Social Safety funds as a result of they’d higher-income jobs throughout their working years, would have benefited essentially the most from Trump’s promise — as a lot as $14,153 for these within the highest tax bracket and receiving $45,000 a yr in Social Safety funds. Even these with whole incomes of $100,000, with $45,000 from Social Safety and $55,000 from different retirement accounts, would have benefited $8,415 a yr from “no taxes on Social Security.”
Below the present Home plan, the advantages for these better-off retirees could be $1,480 and $880, respectively, whereas extra moderate-income retirees would profit $480.
The one retirees who might probably profit extra from the brand new $4,000 tax deduction than they’d have from Trump’s authentic promise are those that gather little or nothing from Social Safety to start with.
“It’s mostly a bait and switch,” stated Jason Furman, a Harvard College economics professor and as soon as a high economist within the Obama White Home. “Most Social Security beneficiaries don’t pay any taxes on benefits already.”
Trump’s White Home didn’t reply to a number of HuffPost queries on the matter.
Julia Demaree Nikhinson / Related Press
Whether or not Trump understands or cares that the brand new $4,000 deduction is a pittance in comparison with what he had promised is unclear. He has over time proven little curiosity in particulars of proposals that don’t personally profit him. Throughout negotiations of the 2017 tax lower invoice, for instance, his principal curiosity within the sprawling laws was to make sure that the decrease company tax charge additionally utilized to restricted legal responsibility corporations, such because the a whole bunch he makes use of to handle his numerous companies.
Calculating taxes on Social Safety advantages is difficult due to the principles designed by Congress and carried out by the IRS that levy taxes primarily based on a person’s whole earnings, however which weigh wages and 401(okay) withdrawals extra closely than earnings coming from Social Safety checks.
For instance, a retiree receiving $24,000 from Social Safety funds and $30,000 from wages or retirement account withdrawals would wind up having $11,300 of the Social Safety funds labeled as taxable and find yourself with an adjusted gross earnings of $41,300.
One other retiree with the identical whole earnings ― $54,000 — however with $45,000 coming from Social Safety and $9,000 from different sources would see simply $3,250 of the Social Safety funds labeled as taxable and wind up with an adjusted gross earnings of $12,250 — a degree that produces no earnings tax invoice in any respect.
It’s these folks like the primary instance, who’re receiving much less in Social Safety funds as a result of they’d lower-paying jobs of their prime working years, who would have been helped disproportionately extra by Trump’s now-abandoned promise to remove taxes on Social Safety funds completely.
In the meantime, the retiree making $54,000 with $45,000 coming from Social Safety wouldn’t have benefited in any respect from Trump’s promise. The one making $54,000 however with solely $24,000 coming from Social Safety would have acquired a tax good thing about $1,356, in response to a HuffPost evaluation.
Below the brand new plan, that retiree will as a substitute get a tax good thing about simply $480.
“This is much less than” what Trump had initially promised, Furman stated. “It was a stupid promise and policy, so frankly, I don’t mind.”
